The former finance chief of X Strategies filed a counter-claim last week alleging the company and its founder engaged in questionable financial practices — actions which “mirror” accusations of embezzlement and financial misconduct that the ex-CFO is facing as part of an ongoing lawsuit from his former employer.
The social media consultancy company, which has ties to President Donald Trump, sued Derek Utley — its former finance chief and co-founder — in September, alleging he had siphoned company funds and used them to gamble at various casinos, CFO Dive reported at the time.
In a Nov. 9 counterclaim, however, attorneys for Utley sued X-Strategies as a counter-defendent for breach of employment and denied X Strategies’ allegations. The 40-page document, which lists a number of defenses including “unclean hands” and a failure to state a civil RICO claim, allege the September suit against Utley tells “half a story” by deliberately omitting evidence that co-founder Alexander Bruesewitz and other principal officers “engaged in comparable conduct.”
“Defendants deny the material allegations of the Complaint and seek relief for the harm this action and its publicity were designed to cause,” the Nov. 9 counterclaim reads.
Bruesewitz, X Strategies’ CEO and a political advisor to Trump, received “substantial compensation and benefits” from company relationships and diverted business opportunities which were not disclosed to Utley, the counterclaim filed in the United States District Court for the Southern District of Florida alleges. That included payments made by Qatari and Syrian individuals which funded lavish hotel stays.
Bruesewitz has denied the claims, noting in a Nov. 11 post on social media site X that he is “not a party to the lawsuit” and “the allegations against me have already been debunked.” The counterclaim does not include Bruesewitz as a counter-defendent.
“This is a wrongful-termination claim brought by a disgruntled former employee against my company,” he wrote in the X post. “He filed the countersuit only after the company sued him for misappropriating millions & millions of dollars.”
Settlement unsettled
The counterclaim is in response to a Sept. 18 suit filed by X Strategies, which states Utley engaged in financial misconduct and embezzled millions in company funds to bankroll an “extravagant lifestyle” and fund a gambling addiction, CFO Dive previously reported. The Palm Beach, Florida-based company provides social media strategy services — including reportedly running several social media accounts for Trump, Politico has reported.
However, the Nov. 9 filing by Utley claims “much of the misconduct the Complaint attributes to Utley mirrors conduct in which Bruesewitz himself engaged.”
Utley and Bruesewitz co-founded the business in 2017, with each holding a 50% stake in X Strategies at the time. While X Strategies claimed Utley served as both chairman and CFO from the company’s founding through to his termination this year, Utley in September comments to CFO Dive said he never served in that role and disputed the allegations.
The September suit, filed under the 1962 Racketeering (RICO) Act, claims Utley took advantage of his “exclusive control” over its finances to siphon funds from X Strategies. He then utilized the funds to gamble at casinos, winning a total of $26 million in a single year before losing $29 million in the same period, resulting in a net loss of $3 million for the company. He then tapped the embezzled funds to bankroll an “extravagant lifestyle,” including the purchase of luxury sports cars and designer jewelry.
However, the counterclaim last week alleges the suit is a “marketing ploy masquerading as a federal lawsuit.”
According to the countersuit, X Strategies and Utley previously entered into a settlement agreement addressing many of the claims then filed against the ex-chairman in September. According to the September suit, Utley, though ultimately terminated, voluntarily stepped down from his roles at the company effective April 3, and Stark Industries, an entity wholly owned by Utley and a named defendant in X Strategies’ suit, voluntarily relinquished its ownership interest.
The counterclaim states that on April 3, Bruesewitz and his holding company, Bruz, signed a confidential settlement agreement with Utley and Stark Industries whereby Utley transferred the 50% ownership stake in X Strategies held by his Stark Industries business to Bruz for no cash, in exchange for “broad releases” from the holding company, Bruesewitz and any person or entity with the ability to make a claim on their behalf.
The settlement was drafted by Holland & Knight, the counterclaim alleges, which currently represents X Strategies in the ongoing suit. Holland & Knight did not immediately respond to requests for comment. Utley declined to comment further beyond the court filings.
Approximately 6 months after the agreement, “X Strategies filed this action making personal attacks on Utley and his company, Stark Defense Industries, in an effort to relitigate the released accusations, inflate them, and attach them to a bare-bones and meritless civil RICO count,” the counterclaim alleges.
Mirrored misconduct
As well as the disputed settlement agreement, the counterclaim also alleges Bruesewitz was not a passive observer of the Company’s financial affairs,” but was an active participant in “substantial commercial transactions” from which he personally profited or failed to disclose to Utley, including financial relationships with foreign investors or governmental representatives associated with Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, and Syria.
Bruesewitz took advantage of such relationships cultivated through X Strategies to obtain personal compensation that was not disclosed to Utley or properly reported as company revenue, the Nov. 9 claim alleges.
That included an alleged $500,000 payment from individuals associated with Qatar, of which Utley was unaware. Utley was also “never provided with contracts, invoices, accounting records, or other documentation explaining its nature or purpose,” the counterclaim states.
Additionally, the Monday filing claims that, when Utley questioned Bruesewitz regarding accommodations for a luxury honeymoon, Bruesewitz said the expenses had been covered by two Syrian billionaires, believed to be Moutaz Al-Khayyat and other members of the Al-Khayyat family.
The expenses included a stay in a luxury hotel with a rate of approximately $15,000 per night, with Bruesewitz honeymooning at the Waldorf Astoria Maldives Ithaafushi, a luxury resort in which the Al-Khayyat family has a controlling stake.
“Ultimately, the Complaint illustrates the familiar principle that those who live in glass houses should not throw stones,” the Nov. 9 filing reads. “Bruesewitz has accused Utley of the very types of conduct in which Bruesewitz himself engaged, including concealing financial arrangements, exploiting Company relationships for personal gain, and diverting valuable business opportunities from X Strategies and its other owner.”