Dive Brief:
- S&P Global Ratings on Wednesday put its BBB rating of Chicago’s general obligation debt outstanding on “CreditWatch with negative implications,” according to a Wednesday release.
- After Chicago CFO Ashlee Gabrysch resigned on Friday, S&P flagged an “elevated” likelihood the debt would be downgraded within the next 90 days due to a current budget stalemate that increases the possibility that the city will use one-time measures to balance its fiscal 2027 budget.
- “We believe the CFO’s resignation adds uncertainty to a budget process,” Scott Nees, director of U.S. Public Finance at S&P Global Ratings, said in an emailed statement. “The CFO’s resignation removes an important player from this process at a critical moment, and the related political fallout has the potential to absorb scarce time and attention that might otherwise be directed to negotiating a more constructive budget outcome.”
Dive Insight:
Gabrysch, who quit just three months after joining City Hall from Fitch Ratings, is the city’s third top finance leader to step down from the role this year.
It hasn’t been a clean break. She resigned last week saying that to continue in the role would compromise her integrity and professional obligations, CFO Dive reported. Mayor Brandon Johnson’s press office battled back, saying in a statement sent to CFO Dive that she was absent during “critical periods of the budget process.”
The Chicago Sun-Times reported that trouble was evident on the first day of budget hearings, when Gabrysch “contradicted [Mayor Brandon] Johnson’s claim that his $17.6 billion pre-election budget was 76% structurally balanced.”
On Wednesday the tensions rose further. In a 45-5 vote Chicago City Council authorized an independent review of the city’s finances that includes a probe into whether the Johnson administration knowingly gave inaccurate financial information about the city’s budget to investors, the council, or the public, according to CBS News.
Johnson’s office said in an emailed statement Thursday that S&P’s notice highlights the risks of an “artificial gridlock.” It also noted that during the past three years his administration identified $860 million in savings and efficiencies, including $60 million in the mayor’s fiscal 2027 budget.
In a statement included in the same email, Acting CFO and Comptroller Michael Belsky said S&P makes clear that the city can avoid a downgrade by passing a balanced budget. “As Acting CFO, I look forward to working with all stakeholders to address the concerns outlined in the CreditWatch rationale and resolve them by passing a balanced budget that works for all Chicagoans and secure the city’s long-term financial future,” Belsky said.
After the S&P warning Chicago Alderman and Finance Chair Pat Dowell said the CFO’s “alarming resignation” must be independently reviewed, according to a statement in a release sent to CFO Dive.
“The City’s credit ratings are already extraordinarily precarious,” Dowell said. “Any further downgrade risks our ability to access the bond market at reasonable interest rates, causing irreparable harm to our ability to move forward with major initiatives and resolve significant liabilities.”