When Nvidia announced Tuesday that it hired executive search firm Heidrick & Struggles to conduct its search for a new CEO, they were following a classic headhunting industry script.
For expertise in conducting executive searches at big public companies, many companies needing to fill their C-suite vacancies turn to five of the biggest firms, known by the acronym SHREK. They include New York-based Spencer Stuart, Chicago-based Heidrick & Struggles, New York-based Russell Reynolds Associates, Zurich-based Egon Zehnder and Los Angeles-based Korn Ferry, according to Shawn Cole, president and co-founder of Cowen Partners Executive Search.
“In a crisis, executive search is as much about restoring shareholder confidence and protecting reputation as finding the right leader,” Cole said. “For a company like NVIDIA, particularly during a scandal or leadership crisis, retaining a recognized executive search firm lends credibility to the succession process.”
Heidrick & Struggles is also a good fit because it has a long history of experience in Silicon Valley, Cole said. The company has previously worked with ON Partners, though those recruitment engagements were for middle management level positions, he said.
Jeff Sanders, vice chair and co-managing partner of H&S’s global CEO and board practice, is leading the search, according to Cole and a report in The Wall Street Journal citing people familiar with the matter. Heidrick & Struggles did not immediately respond to a request for comment.
What H&S and other SHREK firms are, effectively, is the safe choice, Cole said, noting that boards particularly take that position to signal they’re doing their due diligence. They’re so widely perceived to be the blue ribbon option that there’s an old adage, said Cole. It is: “No one ever got fired for hiring Korn Ferry.”
At the same time, if the board isn’t involved, smaller firms can get a shot at big searches. For example, Cole noted that Cowen, a smaller boutique firm, recently handled a public company’s CFO search because the CHRO led the search and did not need to get the board to sign off.
Yet, despite the regularity with which such firms are typically hired, the move was scrutinized on social media. Luke Blaney, a managing director at U.K.-based ARx, an engineering and scientific recruitment consultancy, estimated that Nvidia employs over 1,100 HR and talent acquisition professionals globally and could have taken the search on itself, but they’re not specialists in CEO roles. “Nvidia wants a game changer,” he wrote on his LinkedIn.
The searches are big business. Retained executive search firms generally charge 33.3% of total annual cash compensation plus administrative expenses, with negotiated fee caps around $2 million, Cole said. In Nvidia’s case he’d expect that the next CEO would see anywhere from $50 to $100 million in total annual compensation, including $5 million to $7 million in salary plus bonus.
For now, some of the top contenders for the CEO role at Nvidia include Arm CEO Rene Haas, Nvidia executive Ian Buck, and Colette Kress, CFO Dive previously reported. Kress has served as Nvidia’s CFO since 2013 and was appointed interim CEO — while retaining her finance duties — after company founder and former CEO Jensen Huang resigned from his role last week.